November 28, 2023

YouTube’s resolution to current customers with a clean dwelling feed if their watch historical past is off has utterly ruined the expertise.

YouTube introduced it could cease displaying really helpful movies in customers’ dwelling feeds if their watch historical past was disabled, however few customers have been ready for precisely how unhealthy the expertise can be. Customers are offered with a very clean dwelling feed, save for a message asking the consumer to show their watch historical past again on. The service doesn’t even make suggestions from a consumer’s subscriptions, nor does it present them what new movies from the creators they comply with.

Customers have taken to Reddit to complain in regards to the new function and name out YouTube for being anti-consumer. The actual rub is that even Premium subscribers should not immune from this alteration.

“Although I’m a premium subscriber, Youtube modified to this terrible homepage expertise simply because I’m not turning on my watch historical past and therefore not giving Google my knowledge,” wrote consumer kingcobra0411. “It was displaying trending movies no matter my watch historical past.”

“So it’s, ‘Allow us to take your historical past or we take your really helpful feed,’” wrote consumer sir_swankington. “I swear youtube will get increasingly more anti-consumer each replace.”

One more consumer stated YouTube’s change had an unexpected profit:

My watch historical past is off and now my dwelling web page is clean. At first i used to be upset with no suggestions and was going to seek out methods round this (by no means gonna activate watch historical past) however than I spotted.

I watch alot of youtube and the House web page being off has inadvertently helped me cut back my watch time and made me extra productive. The bizarre half is why they even did it, however oh effectively really feel higher off simply seeing my sub feed.

In response, one other consumer identified that there’s a solution to work round YouTube’s change:

Flip in your watch historical past, watch one video, flip it off once more. It simply doesn’t present something on the frontpage in case your watch historical past is empty (which it’s if you happen to’ve had it all the time turned off)

Given how aggressively anti-consumer YouTube has grow to be, it’s unlikely this workaround will final lengthy. YouTube clearly desires to gather each final scrap of knowledge it could possibly, no matter whether or not a consumer is already paying for YouTuve Premium, so it’s in all probability solely a matter of time till the corporate shuts down this workaround.